I just returned from the meeting of the Maricopa Community College District's (MCCD) Governing Board this evening. Our Student Public Policy Forum (SPPF) group was on hand to present the results of our recent lobbying trip to Washington D.C. to promote the higher education legislative agenda to our elected representatives.
I wasn't able to stay until the end of the meeting, but the first half went well, from what I saw, with one notable exception. Namely, the first person up to speak - a student from Scottsdale Community College who was NOT in our SPPF program - took the opportunity to not only lodge a complaint about the Board, but did so in some of the rudest terms I've ever heard anyone speak at a public policy gathering.
The fellow, whose name escapes me, shambled up to the microphone with his shirttail drooping out of his trousers and pulled out a sheaf of papers on which he'd written his fulminating screed. After he'd accused the whole Board of corruption and began to talk about coverups, "sacrificial lambs" and the "sins of the fathers", he then warmed up to accusing the Board of other ulterior motives and so forth.
It was part rant and part Dr. Bronner's soap label. There seemed to be no real facts in anything he was saying, just a lot of highly charged invective. After a couple of minutes of this undiluted vitriol, Presiding Board Member Rosenthal interrupted him and asked, "Excuse me...what is the bottom line of your complaint?"
At this, the fellow became even more adversarial and suggested that Madam President had derailed him from his rant so as to undermine his freedom of speech, which, and I'm not kidding here, "the Sheriff's office would have something to say about".
When President Rosenthal said that further comments of his insulting nature wouldn't be acceptable, he lashed back with a comment about "it shows where your hearts and minds really are". Which I guess means, if you aren't prepared to just sit there and have me spit insults at you, then you're a bad public servant, or something.
"You're excused," Madame President finally said, to the relief of many in the room, I'm sure.
As the fellow gathered up his papers and prepared to skulk from the room, he said "I just hope the media will take notice of this." For that matter, I hope so, too. He was an excellent cautionary example of how NOT to lobby your public officials.
After he left, Mrs. Rosenthal noted calmly that citizen participation in this forum is most welcome, but it was predicated on a certain standard of courtesy. And, in her opinion, that standard was not being met by the fellow's behavior. I couldn't agree more emphatically.
***
Perhaps 20 minutes later in the meeting, our group was able to speak. After introduction by Vice-Chancellor Helfgot, our Director of the program (Chad Douwstra) spoke briefly and introduced about a half-dozen of us students. We each took perhaps a minute to share some brief impressions and personal relevance of our experience in the SPPF program.
When my turn came, I noted that lobbying is a word that has fallen into disrepute, but it is a critical part of our civic society. To proactively champion an issue or advocate for your values with elected officials is part of the bedrock of our country. The SPPF program taught us not only the mechanics and logistics of
how to do this, but also
why it is important. Inspired by the grotesque example of the rude fellow that had spoken at the beginning of the meeting, I emphasized that we also learned
how to do it in a spirit of collaboration and courtesy. Two principles, I noted, that ought to be part of the foundation of our body politic.
I was concerned that I would be physically able to speak, as I'm nursing a sore throat (my voice did crack once). But it went well. The other students who spoke were superb. I was especially moved by my colleague Chris, who closed for us, drawing the importance of being able to lobby as part of the American experience and how the program enabled us to be a part of that experience more richly than before. In all, the presentation went well and I was extraordinarily proud to be a part of that group.
If anyone would like to find out how to become a part of the SPPF program at their community college, please check with your Student Life Director for more information or send me an email). If you're interested in learning how and why to lobby, as well as developing a network of friends to help you develop in this area, it's an excellent training experience.
And, it's more than just an educational opportunity. As I said to the Governing Board in my own closing comments, to be able to go from volunteering on a campaign to help elect a Congressman to, a few months later, standing in his office in Washington D.C. and championing the issues and legislation that are important to me, was an experience that I will never forget.
I'm extraordinarily grateful for the Board's support of the SPPF program and for being able to take part in it. As soon as I got home, I sent Mrs. Rosenthal an email thanking her and the Board again for the opportunity to speak and their support for the SPPF program. And I also noted how pleased I was with the way she handled the very passionate, but also very rude, fellow who definitely needed to get some training on how to lobby his public officials.
Labels: community college, maricopa, MCCD, Rosenthal, SPPF